Brooklyn Candle Studio Review: Are Sustainable Candles Worth the Price?

Disclosure: This is a sponsored post containing affiliate links. We received compensation and courtesy product from Brooklyn Candle Studio in exchange for our honest review only. All opinions expressed here are our own. Learn more.

by  Kiev Broadwater | Last Updated: 

It’s great to have candles around the house, but overwhelming scents and bright, gaudy jars with ugly graphics on them can make buying them a pain. Brooklyn Candle Studio makes great-smelling candles in modern, minimalist packaging, but is it worth the price tag?

I picked up a few products from Brooklyn Candle Studio to get the lowdown on this New York-based brand and find out if they’re worth shopping with.

Smell that?
The Adult Man Image/Icon Image source: Brooklyn Candle Studio

Brooklyn Candle Studio

The Adult Man Image/Icon The Adult Man Image/Icon The Adult Man Image/Icon The Adult Man Image/Icon The Adult Man Image/Icon

Bottom line: Brooklyn Candle Studio offers eco-friendly candles that are produced in-house in Brooklyn, New York. Their company is centered around sustainability and artistic expression, leading to some great-smelling candles that you can feel better about buying.

Ratings:

The Adult Man Image/Icon  Design The Adult Man Image/Icon The Adult Man Image/Icon The Adult Man Image/Icon The Adult Man Image/Icon The Adult Man Image/Icon
The Adult Man Image/Icon  Quality of Materials The Adult Man Image/Icon The Adult Man Image/Icon The Adult Man Image/Icon The Adult Man Image/Icon The Adult Man Image/Icon
The Adult Man Image/Icon  Value for Money The Adult Man Image/Icon The Adult Man Image/Icon The Adult Man Image/Icon The Adult Man Image/Icon The Adult Man Image/Icon
The Adult Man Image/Icon  Craftsmanship The Adult Man Image/Icon The Adult Man Image/Icon The Adult Man Image/Icon The Adult Man Image/Icon The Adult Man Image/Icon
The Adult Man Image/Icon  Customer Service The Adult Man Image/Icon The Adult Man Image/Icon The Adult Man Image/Icon The Adult Man Image/Icon The Adult Man Image/Icon

Pros:

  • Brooklyn Candle Studio makes high-quality, artisan-made candles and other scented products that smell great
  • Their products are crafted in-house and utilize wax made from soybeans that are grown in America
  • Their candles are petroleum-free, cruelty-free, phthalate-free, and 100% vegan
  • The jars and containers they use feature a sleek, minimalist design

Cons:

  • Their products more expensive than big-box stores, but the scents are more nuanced and less “in-your-face”

As much of a rambunctious teen as I was, a day of mallratting around the local shopping center was never complete without smelling at least half of the inventory in Yankee Candle. 

Why wasn’t I spending my hard-earned wages from slinging Dairy Queen soft serve on these candles? Because their labels were covered in lilies or frosted visages of cranberries and pine needles. 

And that just didn’t fit with my sophisticated aesthetic of KISS and Iron Maiden posters.

Many more years and fewer band posters later, the problem persists.

Candles are just as decorative as they are functional—you’ll be looking at them at least every time you light them and every time you blow them out, so they might as well look nice. Hopefully as nice as they smell.

Brooklyn Candle Studio believes in providing a full sensory experience, which is why they make candles that smell great in packaging with a modern, minimalist aesthetic. They also take a sustainable approach to sourcing and manufacturing, and their candles are made right out of their studio in New York City.

Their products look great and smell great, but are they worth the price? Read my full Brooklyn Candle Studio review below to find out.

What Is Brooklyn Candle Studio?

View this post on Instagram

Brooklyn Candle Studio started as an Etsy side project by creator Tamara Mayne. After she initially built the brand on her own, she turned it into a full-fledged business that provides a wide range of scented products.

Their candles are made by a team of artisans out of their studio in Brooklyn, NY, aiming to provide luxury candles to those looking for great smells and smart packaging.

There’s a wide range of products available on the Brooklyn Candle Studio website, from sprays to diffusers and candles, and these products come in several scents. How they source these scents is part of what makes them unique, as they work with high-end American fragrance houses to get their hands on sustainable and natural-smelling scents.

As another part of their commitment to sustainability, they use soy wax sourced from American soybean farms and lead-free cotton wicks for a contaminant-free burn.

All in all, Brooklyn Candle Studio is a for us, by us, New York City brand that supports a team of skilled artisans and pumps high-quality candles that prioritize design and sustainability.

Things to Consider Before Buying Candles from Brooklyn Candle Studio

Two Brooklyn Candles

Candles are nice to have around. They make your place smell good, and they create a relaxing atmosphere.

However, when they have big, gaudy labels that look like your great aunt’s floral couch, you’ll probably find ways of having them out of your eye line. And that way may end up being not using them at all.

Brooklyn Candle Studio’s candles don’t look cheap. In fact, with their minimalist design, they’re as decorative as they are functional. You can stick a few of these on your nightstand or on the kitchen table without letting out a disapproving sigh every time you go to light one.

This company is also a good choice if you prioritize sustainability. The soy wax and cotton wicks they use provide a clean, eco-friendly burn. You wouldn’t think this would be an issue that needs solving, due to lead-cored wicks being banned in 2003, but they can still be found in candles currently on the market.

When you buy a candle from Brooklyn Candle Studio, you’re investing in New York artisans, top-of-the-line ingredients, and sustainable practices.

Brooklyn Candle Studio Review

Candles

Brooklyn Candles Kyoto Candle Lit

First, we’ll take a look at the brand’s flagship product: their candles. Brooklyn Candle Studio offers both single and double-wick candles in subtle scents that aren’t going to overpower your guests with that trapped-in-an-elevator-at-Macy’s smell. 

Their fragrance sourcing deftness shines through in the way their candles smell. And although they use many synthetic ingredients to produce their fragrances, none of the candles I’ve smelled have had that artificial or sickly-sweet smell you can get from some other candles.

Here are the scents that I picked up from Brooklyn Candle Company and my impression of each one:

  • Santa Fe 
    • Listed scents: Orchid Cactus, Piñon, Palo Santo, Spruce, Woodsmoke, Sage, and Cedar
    • Smells like: Floral and herbaceous, slightly woody
  • Kyoto 
    • Listed scents: Hinoki Cypress, Cedar, Pine, Sandalwood
    • Smells like: Woody, but sweet
  • Fern + Moss 
    • Listed scents: Sage, Lavender, Spruce, Pine, Oakmoss
    • Smells like: Strong herbs with a slight woodiness
  • Woodsmoke 
    • Listed scents: Cedar Leaf, Smoke, Labdanum, Incense, and Leather
    • Smells like: Strong woody smoke 
  • Santal 
    • Listed scents: Hinoki Cypress, Cedar, Pine, Vetiver, and Sandalwood
    • Smells like: A stronger, more floral version of the Kyoto scent
Brooklyn Candle on blue table

The minimalist packaging is a nice touch, and I’m not hesitant to leave these out where my guests might see them. The font is clean and modern, and the plain white labels on the smaller candles can fit in with pretty much any decor. 

These candles smell and look great, but the real value is in supporting artisans who use high-quality ingredients and support sustainability in manufacturing and sourcing. 

Santal Room Mist

Brooklyn Candle Spray Bottle on Table

The Santal Room Mist is handy to have around. A few quick spritzes can freshen up an area without lighting candles or dedicating a full-time diffuser. 

We’ve all done our fair share of Febreze-ing. The room mist from Brooklyn Candle Studio plays by the same rules: it sticks around longer on fabric than in the air, and it provides a nice scent for a while. The difference with this room mist is that instead of smelling like fake hydrangeas, it has a subtle, more natural scent.

Brooklyn Candle Spray Box on Table
Brooklyn Candle Studio Santal Room Mist

A few quick spritzes can freshen up an area without lighting candles or dedicating a full-time diffuser.

Check Best Price
If you click this link and make a purchase, we earn a commission at no additional cost to you.

Fern + Moss Scent Diffuser

Brooklyn Candle Diffuser on Table

I’ll be honest, I’ve never owned a diffuser before. I like the way some of them look, but it wasn’t something I ever saw while shopping around and thought “Yes. I need this.”

The Fern + Moss diffuser from Brooklyn Candle Studio may have sold me on them.

What could be so captivating about some sticks poking out of scented oil? For one, they’re a no-effort way to keep your place smelling nice. This diffuser didn’t fill my entire apartment up with the subtle aromas of ferns and moss—but within a range of 5-7 feet? Lovely.

Brooklyn Candle Diffuser Box on Table

The diffusers from Brooklyn Candle Studio are pretty elegant looking. They don’t look like the goofy new age diffusers you see in that local store that sells all the tie-dye, and I even think they look better than the brand’s candles. No label, just some sleek, black text on a clear, liquid-filled bottle. Like a small decanter—but instead of your finest Cognac, it holds scented oil that makes your place smell nice.

These diffusers also last a surprisingly long time. I’ve had the same one in my bedroom for a week and the oil level has barely moved.

Brooklyn Candle Studio Room Diffuser

The diffusers from Brooklyn Candle Studio are pretty elegant looking. They don’t look like the goofy new age diffusers you see in that local store that sells all the tie-dye, and I think they look better than the brand’s candles.

Check Best Price
If you click this link and make a purchase, we earn a commission at no additional cost to you.

What do Other Reviewers Say About Brooklyn Candle Studio?

Brooklyn Candle Kyoto Candle

A key selling point for some reviewers was that the brand’s subtle scents didn’t upset their sensitive sense of smell like other candles and scented products do.

My Thoughts Overall On Brooklyn Candle Studio

What I Like

  • Brooklyn Candle Studio manufactures its products in-house with local artisans and products sourced from American soy providers and high-end fragrance houses.

  • Their products are scented with natural-smelling, subtle fragrances that aren’t overpowering or artificial-smelling.

  • The minimalist packaging, jars, and bottles that house their products look great anywhere in the house, making them a decorative and functional addition to your space.

  • The sustainable labor and sourcing practices employed by Brooklyn Candle Studio make them a more likely pick when I’m looking around for scented products.

What I Don’t Like

  • Hand-crafted, sustainable products tend to cost more, so you’ll have to decide if that’s worth it for you.

Who is Brooklyn Candle Studio for?

Decorating can be a pain, but it’s important to like the space that you’re spending time in—especially if you’re working from home. Brooklyn Candle Studio makes candles that pull double duty as decorative pieces for your home, allowing you to brighten up the decor in your bedroom or your office while also adding a nice fragrance.

The Verdict

I’ve always loved candles—stepping past the candle aisle at the store without going in is always a hesitant affair, and sometimes a failure altogether.

Brooklyn Candle Company makes luxury candles with top-of-the-line ingredients in a studio space in Sunset Park, Brooklyn. And with their minimalist branding, they seem to have become a household name with decorators, as I’ve come across them in numerous hotels and restaurants here in Chicago.

Their candles are great. They have a subtle, natural scent and I like that they’re made with soy that’s sourced from providers located right here in the U.S.

The diffuser was my favorite product out of the bundle I picked up. After the included diffuser sticks soak up the oil, they add a surprisingly strong fragrance—especially in smaller areas. The bottle for the diffuser also looks fantastic, and the included cork allows you to easily repurpose it after the oil dries up.

If you’re in the market for candles and you prioritize design and sustainability just as much as having something that smells nice, Brooklyn Candle Studio definitely deserves a look.


Shop This Post