/  Style /  Watches

Watch Gang Review (Black Tier): My Thoughts After Signing Up

Disclosure: This is a sponsored post containing affiliate links. We received compensation and courtesy product from Watch Gang in exchange for our honest review only. All opinions expressed here are our own. Learn more.

Dean founded The Adult Man in 2016 with the simple idea to help men navigate adulthood with more confidence via science and expert-backed content that entertains while it informs. Originally one of the site’s primary content writers, Dean’s day-to-day now lies in leading our talented team on that same collective mission. Read full bio.

Last Updated: Feb 23, 2024
15 min read
Watch Gang Black Tier Review William Surprised Look Unboxing Watch Gang Box

A new mystery watch every month sounds pretty cool, but not if you get a new expensive piece of trash.

Our Watch Gang review takes a look at the Black Tier to see which of those two categories this service falls into.

The Adult Man Image/Icon
Watch Gang

Bottom line: If you can let go of the need for total control over what you receive in a subscription box at this price point, Watch Gang is a lot of fun, and a convenient way for you to organically develop your own sense of watch style alongside tens of thousands of fellow watch enthusiasts.

Ratings: The Adult Man Image/IconQuality of Products The Adult Man Image/IconCuration The Adult Man Image/IconValue for Money The Adult Man Image/IconSubscription Management The Adult Man Image/IconPackaging
  • It’s a lot of fun getting a new watch in the mail every month
  • Excellent community for connecting with likeminded watch lovers
  • Great way to try new styles and brands and truly discover what you like in a watch
  • Decent quality consistency at Black tier and above
  • The chance to win a Rolex or TAG every week
  • You can now choose your subscription frequency which adds some much needed flexibility to the service.
  • Very little control over what you receive
  • Over the course of a year’s subscription, you will have paid what you may have spent on your dream watch
  • May not suit guys with skinny wrists due to inability to enter exact sizing preferences
(Get $50 off your first month's subscription with code BIGFIVE)

I first came across Watch Gang when I was researching boxes to feature in my round-up post of the best subscription boxes for men.

Right off the bat, I was pretty intrigued by the mixed reviews I was seeing online.

Watch Gang is unique in that they’re a subscription service that exclusively curates watches. It’s a brave combination of the still-somewhat-skeptically-received subscription box model and the extremely opinionated world of watches.

They’ve also experienced some super impressive growth, ballooning to over 20,000 subscribers in just over two years.

It all sounded like the perfect storm for me to dive into with my own review.

So I reached out to the team at Watch Gang and they hooked me up with my own Black Tier subscription to try. I’ll first break down some background info on Watch Gang and how it all works, before diving into an unboxing on the watch I got.

I’ll then wrap up with my thoughts on whether I think Watch Gang’s Black Tier is worth it.

If you’re already clued up on Watch Gang’s story and how the membership works, feel free to jump ahead to my review.

Let’s get into it.

Heads Up: If you’ve got a higher budget, or you’re more interested in premium microbrand or large name watch brands, you may get more value out of my review of Watch Gang’s Platinum Tier subscription.

What Is Watch Gang?

Watch Gang is an L.A. based subscription service and online community for (you guessed it) watches.

Founder and current CEO, Matthew Gallagher started the company in 2016, inspired by a touching final gesture by his father.

Matthew Gallagher and his Dad
Matthew Gallagher and his Dad (Source)

When Matthew’s father passed, he gave Matthew his Rolex Oyster Perpetual. It was a birth year model, 1953, and his father’s most prized possession.

This idea that there’s a human story behind every watch was inspiring to Matthew. He was driven to get more people enthusiastic about collecting watches that they can pass on to their loved ones.

Six months later, Watch Gang was formed. Read more about Matthew’s personal story here, or check out this video:

My Experience

I signed up for Watch Gang Black Tier.

Watch Gang Black is a $149 / watch subscription. To repeat, this is what makes Black different from the other tiers:

  • You get watches with a list price from $150 to $500
  • Watches are from premium microbrands and large name brands
  • Japanese or Swiss movement

I reviewed the first box, and William reviewed the second (with a video review as well).

Box 1: Charles Hutton Aristocrat Unboxing & Review

Charles Hutton Aristocrat

In my first box I got a Charles Hutton Aristocrat 78468-10I. It’s listed for $285 on the Charles Hutton online store. On eBay, it’s going for anywhere from $100 to $200 brand new.

My Aristocrat came in a fairly stock-standard black box with a removable lid.

Charles Hutton Box black background

The Charles Hutton logo is planted squarely on the top of the box which also features a silver edged trim.

Charles Hutton Aristocrat unboxing

There was a warranty card inside the box which lists the retailer as Watch Gang as well as the date of purchase. This watch came with a 24-month warranty.

Charles Hutton Authenticity Card Warranty Info

Onto the watch itself and this model of Aristocrat is a classic looking black-dial stainless steel chronograph with Seiko Quartz movement. The sub-dials and date window have a silver border.

Charles Hutton Aristocrat 78468 10I Vertical

Interestingly enough, the minute and hour hands are silver, as is the hand on the 24H sub-dial. The rest of the hands are red.

It features a 44mm case which is 11mm in thickness including the glass. There’s a slight pop to the glass, which is sapphire coating on mineral.

Charles Hutton Aristocrat on side black background

The strap is a five-link silver plating stainless steel bracelet. The case is also stainless steel but also polished and brushed. I tend to like that look. It gives the watch a bit more character. The strap has a foldover clamp with the Charles Hutton named logo on the bumper.

Charles Hutton Aristocrat Buckle and Strap Outside on Wooden Stump

It has a standard push/pull crown with a small Charles Hutton logo.

I really like the case back. The large logo with the key specs circling it is a cool touch.

Charles Hutton Aritocrat Case Back

My Overall Thoughts on the Charles Hutton Aristocrat Watch

What I Like

  • I’m a sucker for a stainless steel strap, and this one is great. It’s built solid and it lines up well with the case. It gives the watch a weighty feel which I like.

  • I tested the lume and it’s nice and bright.

  • The large logo looks great on the case back.

What I Don’t Like

  • Personally, I’m not a huge fan of the dial. It looks a little busy, and almost like they tried to squeeze a few too many ideas into the one design. I think it’d work better with one less subdial and/or with the date window moved or removed.

  • The glass is sapphire coating on mineral and not true sapphire crystal, which is a shame, but not a rarity at this price point.

Will I Wear It?

To be honest—this watch hasn’t gotten about as much wrist time as one of my girlfriend’s hair ties. I’m simply not in love with the crowded style of the dial.

I dig the strap and some of the branding elements like the case back. But it’s not the type of chronograph I’d go out and buy for myself. Personally, I prefer a more subtle style.

As a plus, I do think this is the best looking dark dial watch across Charles Hutton’s Aristocrat line. I think the models with the gold hands look even busier. At least the silver on this model blends well with the strap and doesn’t clutter the face any further.

Objectively speaking, for $149 as part of a Watch Gang Black subscription, this isn’t a bad watch at all. It has a popular chrono look to it and I’ve already confirmed that it has good resale value.

Watch Gang Black Tier
(Get $50 off your first month with code BIGFIVE)

If you can let go of the need for total control over what you receive in a subscription box at this price point, Watch Gang is a lot of fun, and a convenient way for you to organically develop your own sense of watch style alongside tens of thousands of fellow watch enthusiasts.

Take Your Quiz Now

Box 2: Thomas Earnshaw Longitude Unboxing & Review

In our second box I (William this time) unboxed a Thomas Earnshaw Longitude ES-8803-SETG-02. Here’s a visual look if video is more your speed:

While I hadn’t heard of the brand, my first impressions were that I really liked the look of the watch. I can tell it’s not something I’ll wear every day, or even every week, but it’s unique and will fit nicely with my navy suit.

Watch Gang Earnshaw 1

But if you watched the video above, you know I wasn’t impressed with the unboxing experience. It looked like whoever packed the watch threw it in from half-court.

I’ve unboxed a lot of watches in my day, and I hardly care about the unboxing experience. But as I’ve written more and more, I’ve learned that a lot of my readers are doing research for potential gifts. While I don’t think a bad presentation is a deal-breaker for anyone thinking about buying a watch as a gift, it’s definitely a consideration.

That said, if you’re shopping for yourself and you just care about the quality of the watch, a sloppy packing job doesn’t matter as much (at least to me).

Watch Gang Earnshaw 3

The face of the Earnshaw Longitude quickly makes up for it though—it’s striking.

If I had to put it in a design category, I’d say it’s something like fancy-steampunk.

The most fascinating feature is the open-heart Japanese automatic movement, which starts firing away as you pick the watch up. Just above that is a 24-hour dial set against a textured blue backdrop.

Watch Gang Earnshaw 6

Two silver bars hold the indices, which mark 11-3 in roman numerals, and 5-8 in arabic numerals. 4, 9, and 10 are intentionally missing, though the design is balanced and intriguing.

With a 42mm case width and a 13.5mm height (100g weight) this is a hefty, sturdy watch, especially when paired with the stainless steel mesh band.

I couldn’t find any information about the crystal on the Thomas Earnshaw website, the instruction manual, nor through Watch Gang. Based on the glare, plus the way water beads on the crystal, my guess is that we’re dealing with a sapphire coated mineral crystal. I’m disappointed that there’s no information on such a standard feature.

Watch Gang Earnshaw 5

The watch came with two bands, which is a nice bonus. Watch Gang doesn’t promise multiple bands so it’s cool they included another band for versatility.

The second band is blue imitation crocodile leather, which just so happens to be my least favorite style. I guess I just don’t understand the imitation crocodile leather look.

But the mesh band is outstanding, and I love the way it looks and feels. It’s not pinchy and it’s easy to adjust.

As I mentioned earlier, this timepiece runs on a 24 jewel Japanese automatic movement. Again, there isn’t more information on the brand’s website about the specific model. But given the reputation Japanese movements have, I’m confident this is a solid and reliable caliber.

Watch Gang Earnshaw Caseback

Overall, I’m happy with the style. After my initial glance and research, I felt confident I scored a solid value at $149.

But nothing can ruin your contentment like a quick trip to eBay.

This watch retails on the Thomas Earnshaw website for 600 British pounds, which equates roughly to $750 USD (at the time of writing).

But before we get too excited, the price was much lower on eBay with the same model going for $150 USD.

Ah, good old online watch buying price discrepancies.

Still, at Watch Gang’s Black Tier subscription price of $149 (even less if you use some of the discounts we’re offering), this watch is good value.

My Overall Thoughts on the Thomas Earnshaw Longitude

What I Like

  • The open-heart automatic movement is visually striking and makes this a unique timepiece unlike any other in my collection.

  • Polished stainless steel and navy is a classic color combo that will work well in my wardrobe. That, paired with the mesh band, makes for a great balance of classic style and cutting-edge design.

  • It’s nice to see that I have the option of making a profit reselling this watch—that said, I like the style and I’m going to hang on to it.

What I Don’t Like

  • There wasn’t much information about this watch anywhere. Knowing details (like whether it’s mineral or sapphire crystal) about the quality and construction of my watches makes me feel good wearing them.

  • It doesn’t seem like there was much time or attention put into packaging this watch up.

Will I Wear It?

$149 is a decent price for a timepiece like the Earnshaw Longitude.

The unique design, automatic movement, and quality stainless mesh band result in a watch that I’m glad to add to my collection.

I probably won’t wear it every day or every week—but I already know the few outfits it’ll look stunning with. For me, that’s enough to keep it around.

Knowing that this model is fetching $150 on eBay is also comforting.

Watch Gang delivered solid value with our second box and overall I’m happy with this one.

Watch Gang Black Tier
(Get $50 off your first month with code BIGFIVE)

If you can let go of the need for total control over what you receive in a subscription box at this price point, Watch Gang is a lot of fun, and a convenient way for you to organically develop your own sense of watch style alongside tens of thousands of fellow watch enthusiasts.

Take Your Quiz Now

My Overall Thoughts on Watch Gang Black Tier

What I Like

  • Like most subscription services, it’s a lot of fun to get a new watch in the mail every month. You feel like you’re treating yourself, particularly when with Watch Gang, the actual watch you get is totally random.

  • The community. Watch Gang runs a special group for its subscribers where you can buy, sell, and trade watches (note that the majority of users in the community do seem to be U.S. based) or just chat about them. The group is known for having a really relaxed vibe and not overwhelmed by the snobbery you often find within some watch groups and forums.

  • Sometimes you get a watch that is exceptional value for money when lined up against your subscription cost.

  • The service is a really effective way of trying out a bunch of new and different brands and styles that you otherwise may not have found on your own. This then allows you to figure out what you like, and then make a call on what kind of watch you’d like to save up for.

  • You can now choose your subscription frequency. You have the choice of monthly, quarterly, or on-demand, which I think adds some much needed flexibility to the service.

What I Don’t Like

  • You don’t have any real control over what you’re going to receive. While it probably wouldn’t work for Watch Gang’s business model, it would be great to have a little more control over what you get.

  • Because of the cost, there’s more risk compared to other subscription boxes. There’s a real chance you’ll receive a watch that you won’t ever want to wear. But to be fair, the risk is alleviated somewhat by the fact that you’re quite likely to be able to resell every watch for at least the cost of your Watch Gang subscription.

  • Watch Gang has been known to send larger faced 40mm+ watches and don’t allow you to enter your exact sizing preferences.

Watch Gang’s Black Tier is for you if:

  • You’re a new watch enthusiast who’s interested in a journey of watch discovery
  • You’re already a watch lover and you want to try new watches
  • You like subscription boxes
  • You have disposable income
  • You like the idea of being part of an active community of watch lovers
  • You’re a fan of Rolex or TAG and you’d like to be in the running to win one

Watch Gang may not be for you if:

  • You don’t have disposable income
  • You don’t like subscription boxes
  • You’re a certified watch snob (you know who you are)
  • You only wear watches with a very specific case width

Join Watch Gang

Watch Gang Black Tier
(Get $50 off your first month with code BIGFIVE)

If you can let go of the need for total control over what you receive in a subscription box at this price point, Watch Gang is a lot of fun, and a convenient way for you to organically develop your own sense of watch style alongside tens of thousands of fellow watch enthusiasts.

Take Your Quiz Now

Or use code BIGFIVE to get $50 off your first month of Platinum or Original Tier:

[coupon id=”13491″]

How Does Watch Gang Work?

Watch Gang partners with both new and historic watch brands around the world to deliver you a brand new watch style every month.

It’s no different from most other curation-based subscription services. You choose a plan and get a thing in the mail every month.

When signing up, you’re presented with different styles of watches to vote yea or nay on. It’s a bit like watch Tinder:

Watch Gang Sign Up Survey

Their system will tell you once you’ve voted on enough watches for it to know your style. But you can keep on choosing if you want to really nail it down.

Watch Gang Tiers

Watch Gang Price Tiers

Once you’ve made your style choices, you then lock into one of three monthly pricing tiers:

  • Original: $74 / watch (list price up to $150)
  • Black: $149 / watch (list price up to $500)
  • Platinum: $399 / watch (list price up to $1,500) [read my hands-on review of Platinum]

(use code BIGFIVE for 50% off your first month)

Clearly, the more expensive the level of subscription, the higher the retail value of the watch you’ll receive each month.

And as you’d expect, the prestige of brands and quality of movement rises as you transition up each tier:

  • Original: Fashionable, quality watches, with some name brands thrown in (Miyota or Seiko movement)
  • Black: Premium microbrands and some brand names (Japanese or Swiss movement)
  • Platinum: Premium microbrands and large name brands (Japanese or Swiss Automatic movement)

You then choose your subscription frequency (this is a 2019 udate to the service). You now have the choice of getting a new watch monthly, quarterly, or on-demand, which I think adds some much needed flexibility to the service.

Overall, I found the online signup process to be pretty straightforward. It took me about five minutes from start to finish.

Watch Gang Black Tier
(Get $50 off your first month with code BIGFIVE)

If you can let go of the need for total control over what you receive in a subscription box at this price point, Watch Gang is a lot of fun, and a convenient way for you to organically develop your own sense of watch style alongside tens of thousands of fellow watch enthusiasts.

Take Your Quiz Now

Retail Value

Watch Gang promise to send you watches that have a list price (also known as manufacturer’s suggested retail price or MSRP) of up to five times the cost of your monthly subscription.

It’s important to note here that when it comes to watches, list price and actual market value can vary significantly.

Based on the many other Watch Gang reviews I’ve read, while you’re likely to get watches that you can resell at a market value that meets or slightly exceeds your subscription cost, it’s rare that you’ll be able to successfully resell a Watch Gang watch at its list price and make epic profits.

As with all things, the true value of something is only what others are willing to pay.

Membership Details

Every watch you’re sent is yours to keep. Watch Gang isn’t a lending club.

You can also choose to gift a subscription to someone. This process is identical except you can’t select style preferences.

Regardless of tier, if you’re a member, you’re eligible for all flash sales and giveaways, including their famous weekly TAG and Rolex giveaways.

You’ll also become a member of Watch Gang’s private community where you can buy, sell, trade, or simply shoot the breeze with other members about all things watches.

Watch Gang Rolex / TAG Weekly Giveaway

Yep, you read that right.

Every Tuesday one Watch Gang member wins a TAG, and every Friday, another wins a Rolex.

Watch Gang’s, Founder & CEO, Matthew Gallagher explains his reasoning for the giveaway in this interview:

Grail watches have traditionally been something you would buy during a milestone, like graduating, getting a raise, or getting married. I wanted to give everyone a chance to get the Grail they’ve always aspired to own, regardless of where they are in life. Plus, the Grail watch is something they can pass down to their kids…just like my dad did for me.
Matthew Gallagher, Watch Gang Founder & CEO

Watch Gang has between 20,000 and 30,000 members, and so while you still need to be lucky, your chances are not lottery-level-bad to win.

They announce all their monthly winners on their YouTube channel, like this:

They also do smaller giveaways three other days every week—here’s the full list.

Final Thoughts: Is Watch Gang’s Black Tier Worth It?

Watch Gang Earnshaw 2

Alright, I hear what you’re thinking.

Two watches is a pretty small sample size.

And you’re totally right. It’s tough to make a call on Watch Gang after getting just a few watches. Particularly when the first watch didn’t really nail it on my own personal style.

But to me, Watch Gang is no different to other curation focused subscription boxes. It’s all about the long game.

Approach it as a fun way to learn more about watches in general. And more importantly—for you to get a better understanding of what it is that you truly love in a watch.

Yep, we’re getting all Tony Robbins up in here. It’s about finding yourself. It’s about finding yourself when it comes to watches. It’s about watching yourself.

Ok, too far.

But in all seriousness, you’ll learn something new about your own taste in watches with every box you open.

You can do all the reading in the world online, but there’s nothing like holding a watch in your hands to truly appreciate how you feel about it.

And to me, it’s no surprise that over 20,000 people have signed up to Watch Gang to get that feeling.

Their private community, flash sales, and giveaways are also nice perks and they do help you to feel connected with other likeminded watch lovers.

If you’re ready for a journey, Watch Gang is worth it.

Watch Gang Black Tier
(Get $50 off your first month with code BIGFIVE)

If you can let go of the need for total control over what you receive in a subscription box at this price point, Watch Gang is a lot of fun, and a convenient way for you to organically develop your own sense of watch style alongside tens of thousands of fellow watch enthusiasts.

Take Your Quiz Now

You can always sell the watches that you don’t like. And because you’re getting them at three to five times list price, you’ll usually be able to at least break even if you sell.

Although my first watch was not to my personal taste, as a team, we’re much happier about the second one.

I’ve read that at Black Tier and above you’ll receive more hits than misses, and resale value is a lot better.

And this mirrors my own experience because I really liked the first watch I got for my Watch Gang Platinum Tier subscription.

Watch Gang Platinum Tier
(Get $50 off your first month with code BIGFIVE)

While Watch Gang’s Platinum Tier raises the stakes, it also offers better resale value, while still providing watch enthusiasts with the same incredibly fun way of exploring new watches on the regular.

Take Your Quiz Now

But your mileage may vary. Like with anything, go with what your budget allows.

Start your quiz now to get started with Watch Gang.