4 Easy Ways To Identify Good vs Bad Quality Footwear

This post contains affiliate links. If you click on a link and make a purchase, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Learn more.

by  Paul Cotter | Last Updated: 

Growing up in a large family taught me a lot about the true value of a dollar.

You see, my Mom and Dad were (and still are) super frugal.

I was the youngest of four boys and the last stop in a series of hand-me-downs that lasted well into my teen years.

I learned very early on that it’s better to focus on quality over quantity.

To repair things and not throw them away.

And always take care of what you have.

But I was also taught that for some things, you should always spend up.

My Dad would tell my brothers and I that men should own a quality set of tools, a trusted wristwatch, and a well-fitting suit.

Oh, and at least one pair of good quality shoes.

And now that I’m older, I appreciate the wisdom my Dad was trying to impart.

It pays to only buy quality footwear.

Unfortunately, we no longer live in a time of small-town shoemakers and cobblers who custom tailor shoes to precision.

That’s right:

Finding quality footwear in today’s world of big brands and mass production takes a little bit more knowledge and research than it used to.

In this guide, I’ll show you the things you should be looking for when shopping for a new pair of quality shoes. You’ll also learn what you should steer clear of.

Let’s shuffle into it (I couldn’t resist).

Quality of the Upper Materials

View from above of brown leather dress shoes and polka dot socks

A shoe upper refers to anything above the outsole.

The quality of the uppers determines how your shoes will age and how good (or bad) they look over time.

Bad quality shoes usually use cheap upper materials like plastic, low-grade leathers, and thin suede.

When it comes to leather goods it’s important to note the golden rule:

Not all leather is created equal. This is especially true for men’s footwear.

For the very best in casual, work and winter footwear, stick to full grain leather.

Full grain leather is durable, breathable and molds to your feet with repeated wear.

Discount Available
Oliver Cabell Low 1
(New Year Sale: Get 25-50% off with code OC25)

The Low 1 is Oliver Cabell's most popular shoe. It boasts a classic low-profile silhouette, with color options that are expressive, but not overly trendy or unprofessional.

Check Best Price Read Our Review
If you click this link and make a purchase, we earn a commission at no additional cost to you.

It’s natural texture also allows your shoes to age with grace and develop an attractive patina over time.

More formal dress shoes will use fine leathers such as calfskin, scotch grain or authentic patent leather. Fine leathers need more care than full-grain leather, but the payoff comes from their quality.

MYRQVIST Granhult Dark Brown Calf Chelsea

I always figured a whole-cut leather goodyear welted Chelsea under $300 would never exist. That was until I found the Myrqvist Granhult. Handcrafted in Portugal, this sleek dressy Chelsea is finished with a studded rubber sole and offers a heck of a lot of value for its modest price point.

Check Best Price
If you click this link and make a purchase, we earn a commission at no additional cost to you.

What to Avoid

Avoid footwear brands that don’t disclose the kind of upper material used.

Some leather such as bonded or corrected leather isn’t leather at all. It’s leather mixed with plastic and other chemicals.

Some manufacturers will disclose, but they’ll be sneaky about it. They’ll describe their uppers as “genuine leather”, when in fact, they’re not leather at all.

Cheap leathers will leave creases, discolor with age, and peel over time.

The result? An ugly pair of shoes.

AKA, a new toy for my dog.

Construction Quality

Stitched vs glued leather dress shoes

A shoe’s construction is how the uppers and soles hold together.

There are two main ways shoes are constructed; stitched and glued.

High-quality shoes are almost always stitched. This means that the uppers and outsoles are stitched together with thread.

Types of stitched constructions include Goodyear welt, blake stitching and storm welts.

MYRQVIST Äppelviken Black Calf Oxford

The ideal affordable black plain cap toe Oxford doesn't exi---oh, wait. When I first saw that this came in at under $250 I had to do a double take. These beauties are handcrafted in Portugal with a goodyear welted construction and made from full grain French leather. If you don't already have your formal dress shoes locked down, these are well worth a look.

Check Best Price
If you click this link and make a purchase, we earn a commission at no additional cost to you.

Stitched constructions can be repaired over time. This means that you can replace your outsole when it wears out or do minor repairs to the shoes as needed.

Glued construction is what the name implies. The uppers are glued to the sole instead of stitched.

The pros and cons of a glued construction are pretty straightforward.

Glued shoes are cheaper and easier to manufacture. The downside is they cannot be repaired or resoled which means you get permanent wear over time.

What to Avoid

Most athletic shoes are glued due to mass production.

Good quality dress shoes should never be glued, and in fact, neither should casual shoes.

Glued shoes will almost always fall apart over time. Since they cannot be repaired, you’ll be stuck with worthless shoes that have to be binned instead of resoled.

Production Quality

Rows of leather dress shoes in a store

Determining footwear production quality involves taking a closer look at how the shoes are made.

The highest quality footwear brands handcraft their shoes and boots in small batches.

While cheap shoe manufacturers usually mass produce their footwear in overseas factories.

I’ll let you guess which method of production produces the better quality shoe.

MYRQVIST Skytteholm Chocolate Suede Oxford

The full leather and cork Goodyear welted construction ensures these will last a long time, and the Chocolate Suede from CF Stead tannery in England ensures they'll look good while doing it.

Check Best Price
If you click this link and make a purchase, we earn a commission at no additional cost to you.

Handcrafted shoes are often made with better quality materials. And because they’re hand-stitched, they receive higher attention to detail during construction.

A brand may state that their shoes are “handcrafted” or “handmade”. When this is the case, that line will usually be available in limited runs only due to the extra production time.

Some examples of handcrafted footwear brands include Crockett and Jones, Helm Boots and Allen Edmonds.

What to Avoid

If you’re shopping for quality, avoid mass-produced footwear brands.

They have a pattern of using cheaper materials and tend to cut corners to save on costs. Mass production is the opposite of attention to detail. You’ll run into more defects and shoddy construction.

Price

Price should never be your sole determining factor in judging if a shoe is of high quality. Instead, use price to give you a general clue of where the shoe lands on the quality scale.

The easiest judgment of quality is at the cheaper end.

High-quality materials and craftsmanship are expensive. If a shoe costs $40, it’s safe to bet that the brand has cut a few corners when it comes to quality.

Gucci vs Rancourt And Co loafers

But high priced shoes can also be deceiving. Particularly luxury brands.

A great example of this is comparing Gucci vs Rancourt & Co. Both brands make horse bit loafers.

But on a side by side comparison of materials, the $730 Gucci loafers are not of better quality than Rancourt & Co’s $340 handcrafted calfskin loafers.

The truth is, marketing plays a huge role in perceived quality.

Comparing Red Wing Iron Ranger vs Wolverine 1000 Mile Boots is another good example.

Red Wing Iron Ranger Boots vs Wolverine 1000 Mile boots

Although they’re made from different leathers and outsoles, the brands are of similar quality.

Both Red Wing and Wolverine boots use full grain leather uppers and have Goodyear welt constructions.

What to Avoid

Avoid footwear that is too cheap. There is a difference between a great quality shoe that goes on sale for $50 and a shoe that is $50 year round.

Cheap shoes almost always equal cheap materials that deteriorate over time.

On the flip side, don’t fall into the luxury trap. Expensive does not equal quality. This is why we’re fans of transparent pricing shoemakers like Oliver Cabell with their famous Low 1:

Discount Available
Oliver Cabell Low 1 - White
(New Year Sale: Get 25-50% off with code OC25)

The Low 1 is Oliver Cabell's most popular shoe, and once you have it in your hands you'll know why. Made in Italy from full grain calfskin Italian leather, it boasts a handsome low-profile silhouette and punches well above its weight for its price point.

Check Best Price
If you click this link and make a purchase, we earn a commission at no additional cost to you.

Pay attention to the type of leather, construction and production methods before splurging on a super expensive pair of shoes.

Heads up: This is a guest post by Paul. The views expressed in this article are his own & The Adult Man takes no legal responsibility for any consequence regarding the information in this post. 

Get the Results With Women You've Always Wanted
Dating in the Wild
(Get $20 off with code TAM20)

Join hundreds of men transforming their dating lives with our revolutionary dating and masculinity 4+ hour video course. Launched fresh in 2023, it will equip you with the exact mindsets and dating strategies you need to win with women and become a higher value man in the process.

Learn More